Skip to main content

4 Ways Best Buy Could Have Improved My Shopping Experience

This Picture sums up the shopping experience I had at Best Buy when looking for wearable fitness technology---empty shelves and no help.

I was back in the market for a wearable fitness device and decided to go to Best Buy and pick one up. Previously, I had three Jawbone Up wrist bands and the batteries wouldn't hold a charge. Jawbone replaced the bands for me but when the third one died after a couple of months I gave up. The company said you could wear them continuously, even in the shower, but think the waterproof aspect wasn't up to par. I then switched to a cheaper Fitbit that clipped to my clothes. I put it in the laundry and washed it. That one was now dead and I decided to give up on it.

Fast forward about a year, and I decided to dip my toes back in the market. I went to the wearable technology aisle at Best Buy and was greeted with a number of really nice point-of-purchase displays from the various manufacturers. Clearly, a lot of money had gone it the displays and they were helpful to the consumer in explaining the step ups between models.

Fitbit broke down the models into "everyday", "active" and "performance" so you could determine the type of user you are. It is color coded and the step up between each product is easy to see.

Jawbone Up has an equally impressive display with clear feature lists that indicated step ups between products. In addition, they show how it works and connectivity options.

Polar broke their product line into "activity", "performance" and "fitness". The features are a bit more cumbersome to go through and their product line was smaller. This is a well established brand (I remember the old strap on heart rate monitors that were incredibly uncomfortable.)

Next came Garmin. Not well known in the wearable technology market but certainly in navigation. They had a surprising number of product but it was difficult to see the difference between them. Some were band style some were watch style.

Pebble is really in the Smartwatch category but I knew several people who owned them and loved them. The display was relatively helpful. It was a bit more money that I wanted to spend at this time.

There was also a Samsung Smartwatch with even less information.

Just to add to the confusion was Basis Peak, Hazer Nabu X, Fusion and for some reason breathometer, which measures alcohol consumption, was thrown into the mix.

So with all of these options to choose from I had to narrow it down. I decided to go with the three brands I knew most about Jawbone UP, Fitbit and Polar. I finally glanced down to see how much merchandise was even on the shelf.

The selection for Jawbone Up was meager to say the least.

Most of the shelf for the other products looked like this.

Fitbit was well stocked so that pretty much narrowed my choice down to Fitbit. Of course, each product was in this handy theft/customer deterrent plastic case. I had already spent so much time there, I just wanted to buy it and get out. I pretty much had to look at each package because nothing was organized on the shelf

I got home and started to critique the package (like I always do with any purchase I make.) It had this useful sizing guide on the side of the package that I didn't even notice while in store because of the plastic case:

Then I check the front of the box. UGGGGH. I had purchased a size large.

Back to the store I went hoping they would even have a small. At this point I had spent a better part of 1 1/2 hours to make the purchase. I was more than frustrated. The exchange was simple so Best Buy gets points for that but not much else.

So that is all leading up to my 4 ways Best Buy could have improved my in-store shopping experience:
  1. I know Best Buy doesn't want to stock their shelves with a lot of merchandise, especially merchandise that is expensive and comes in a small box that can easily be stolen. If you must use the plastic boxes, then carry fewer brands so that enough stock is there for customers to get the correct product.
  2. If the first suggestion isn't an option, stock mock boxes that that manufacturer provides. This way, the customer will be able to get to all of the useful information on the package as they drill down to their final selection, such as color and size. Have the boxes well merchandised. Once a customer brings the box to purchase, get the actual product and return the mock box to the shelf.
  3. If the mock boxes take up too much room, I have seen Best Buy use cards that the customer brings to the register. Have the card contain the exact same information the manufacturer has on the package. But don't have the cards look generic have them branded by manufacturer so they are easier to find. Also, have the content designed by branded by manufacturer as well.
  4.  Finally, how about a little help from a Best Buy employee. I was there at noon during the week. There were more employees than customers. I was in the aisle for over 1/2 hour and not one sales person approached me. My luck with finding knowledgeable staff hasn't been great in the past but maybe someone could have told me if they had other product available. 
Just in case anyone wants the 2015 c|net recommendations check out this link

Patty Jensen is Vice President of Account Services at JDA Inc, a graphic design firm that specializes in supporting companies' branding and retail efforts with a Unified Marketing approach. To learn more, click here.


Popular posts from this blog

Packaging: 10 Steps to a Better Process

1. Prioritize. Prioritize. Prioritize. When three people are talking to you, you can’t hear them all. The same is true for design. Visual priority must be established from the very beginning of the design process. If every item is given primary importance, nothing becomes important. The visual priorities are what drive how all creative will be judged. The design firm should include as part of their creative brief, a hierarchy of 5 communication points for the front of the package. This includes 1) brand 2) product name 3) why-to-buy statement 4) feature points 5) product image. 2. Come together. Everyone has an opinion, so clear project objectives are vital to any job. Consensus regarding the creative brief must be obtained from the people expected to judge the package design from within your corporation. Without this consensus, the design process will fall apart. Without clearly stated, agreed-upon objectives, you are not able to provide constructive feedback. As soon as you start t

Let Your Packaging Sell Your Product, Not a Funny Name!

So I ran across this product while I was traveling in NY and needed some earplugs.  I can't sleep without them. Earplugs are notoriously hard to find on shelf so I had to scan many products. I came across this product and got quite a chuckle. I don't think I need to explain why (To be fair, it was awhile ago, and the package design could have changed since then.): Zim's Crack Creme---we can assume that Zim is the pharmacist who created this all-natural herbal wonder cream (creme) for your crack. Or is that really what this means. Surly it couldn't. We design packaging and I couldn't help but analyze this package as I would for a client. The first thing we help our clients do is to prioritize the elements on the front of the package. What is the most important thing to communicate? The name? The brand? The why-to-buy? The features? Obviously, Zim felt the name of the product was most important. But if the name of the product doesn't really convey what it doe

New and Not Necessarily Improved

A story in the March 3, 2009 issue of the LA Times regarding the unfavorably received new Pepsi brand redesign reminded me of another recent unsuccessful redesign—the one for Tropicana orange juice. A few months ago, I was in a Target store buying some orange juice. I usually get the Tropicana brand, and was disappointed when I didn't see any in the cases. I just saw a bunch of unfamiliar cartons that I immediately wrote off as "not Tropicana" and kept looking around. It was only during a second pass that I realized that these new cartons were indeed Tropicana. Wow, I thought, that's a pretty radical new look. Gone were any vestiges of familiarity--the funky old-style logo, and especially the orange with the straw stuck in it. The new carton is dominated by a large shot of a tasteful-looking (not necessarily tasty-looking) glass of orange juice, with the word "Tropicana" in an unfamiliar sans serif font and green color turned 90ยบ clockwise along the side. T