Skip to main content

Costco: The Good, The Bad & The Meh

Even though Costco doesn't carry that many SKUs (only 4,000 compared to Walmart's 150,000), the size of the warehouse space and the variety of product can be overwhelming. During any trip I make to Costco, I always take a look at some of the packaging and displays and note what grabs my attention and others that are just so-so.  Since Costco is self serve, displays are the silent sales person. In addition, if there are only 2-3 brands in a category the packaging and display must work harder to capture the consumer's attention and sell the product.

The Good

iHome: I was immediately drawn to this iHome packaging and display:

The display invites you to take a closer look. The pallet wrap is colorful and tells the customer what the product is: A Rechargable Bluetooth Speaker with Speakerphone.

The packaging has a hologram that changes color as you walk around the display which mimics how the product performs.


The pallet holds a counter top type display that demonstrates the product which is interactive and inviting.
iRobot Roomba: Below is another display and packaging I thought provided great content allowing customers to make a buying decision while in store.

The Roomba packaging is very clean and calls out key features. Since the packaging is bilingual, its is great the copy was kept to a minimum.


The additional details provided on the side of the display can help to close the sale for those undecided buyers.

The Bad

Most of the examples below are packaging design. Granted, not every manufacturer can afford the types of displays listed above. This means that the packaging has to work extra hard to present the product. In the following cases, the packaging designs are so cluttered that it is hard to find the benefits of the product.

This is a classic case of a package trying to communicate too much. Can you tell at a glance what this product is? It is an HD Video Security DVR. I could do an entire blog on how this could be improved.

The brand stands out but the features are lost in the gold bars with white type. When comparing this to the packaging below for Costco's house brand Kirkland, this stands out much better on the store floor

The product photography is really nice. Only a few features are called out on the front. I think Kirkland could be slightly larger though.

Another case where the package is just too busy and tries to communicate too much to the consumer. It is overwhelming.

 The Meh

These packaging and displays missed opportunities to really showcase the product and give the consumer more information to make a buying decision.

This is a real missed opportunity. The packaging is nice and clean but the bottom of pallet wrap doesn't draw the customer to the display at all. Color could have been used to add some excitement

This is a really clean package design but in a store like Costco, the consumer needs to know what the product is to even be considered. In very small type, it says what it is: A Home Control Starter Kit. A clear benefit needs to be stated on the front of this packaging.

HP is a premium, well known, brand. This packaging is just OK. I like how the side of the box completes the image of the printer. This works well when stacked in a a club store. However, this has too much information and has no clear benefit stated on the front of the box.

I can guess that this might be a home security system because of the cameras on the packaging. However, all of the elements on the front of this box are the same size. Nothing stands out. Under the brand name it states: True High Definition 1080p. Then beneath that, even smaller and harder to read is "Security Camera System". It is always difficult displaying copy when there are three languages on the front of a package but it can function better than this package.
Because of the business I'm in, even a quick trip to the store ends up being a critique of sorts. These examples really drive home how important packaging and displays are to selling more product—especially in a club store environment.

Patty Jensen is Vice President of Account Services at JDA Inc, a graphic design firm that specializes in supporting companies' branding and retail efforts with a Unified Marketing approach. To learn more, click here.

Comments

Unknown said…
You are exactly right. The packaging and display must do the selling at Costco. Interesting perspective.
JDA, Inc. said…
Thanks for taking the time to read our blog. I'm happy you found it interesting.
Steph Han said…
Great observations! Do you know if many companies do Costco-specific packaging to address some of these issues? I imagine, though, that if it can work in Costco it could work anywhere.
JDA, Inc. said…
Sorry I didn't respond this this earlier. Some of my clients do Costco specific SKUs but it isn't necessarily because the need to address these issues. It is because Costco has specific guidelines. In my opinion, a well designed package can work anywhere. But if you are if your products best retail outlet is Costco, pay attention to the challenges/

Popular posts from this blog

Packaging: 10 Steps to a Better Process

1. Prioritize. Prioritize. Prioritize. When three people are talking to you, you can’t hear them all. The same is true for design. Visual priority must be established from the very beginning of the design process. If every item is given primary importance, nothing becomes important. The visual priorities are what drive how all creative will be judged. The design firm should include as part of their creative brief, a hierarchy of 5 communication points for the front of the package. This includes 1) brand 2) product name 3) why-to-buy statement 4) feature points 5) product image. 2. Come together. Everyone has an opinion, so clear project objectives are vital to any job. Consensus regarding the creative brief must be obtained from the people expected to judge the package design from within your corporation. Without this consensus, the design process will fall apart. Without clearly stated, agreed-upon objectives, you are not able to provide constructive feedback. As soon as you start t...

New and Not Necessarily Improved

A story in the March 3, 2009 issue of the LA Times regarding the unfavorably received new Pepsi brand redesign reminded me of another recent unsuccessful redesign—the one for Tropicana orange juice. A few months ago, I was in a Target store buying some orange juice. I usually get the Tropicana brand, and was disappointed when I didn't see any in the cases. I just saw a bunch of unfamiliar cartons that I immediately wrote off as "not Tropicana" and kept looking around. It was only during a second pass that I realized that these new cartons were indeed Tropicana. Wow, I thought, that's a pretty radical new look. Gone were any vestiges of familiarity--the funky old-style logo, and especially the orange with the straw stuck in it. The new carton is dominated by a large shot of a tasteful-looking (not necessarily tasty-looking) glass of orange juice, with the word "Tropicana" in an unfamiliar sans serif font and green color turned 90ยบ clockwise along the side. T...

Let Your Packaging Sell Your Product, Not a Funny Name!

So I ran across this product while I was traveling in NY and needed some earplugs.  I can't sleep without them. Earplugs are notoriously hard to find on shelf so I had to scan many products. I came across this product and got quite a chuckle. I don't think I need to explain why (To be fair, it was awhile ago, and the package design could have changed since then.): Zim's Crack Creme---we can assume that Zim is the pharmacist who created this all-natural herbal wonder cream (creme) for your crack. Or is that really what this means. Surly it couldn't. We design packaging and I couldn't help but analyze this package as I would for a client. The first thing we help our clients do is to prioritize the elements on the front of the package. What is the most important thing to communicate? The name? The brand? The why-to-buy? The features? Obviously, Zim felt the name of the product was most important. But if the name of the product doesn't really convey what it doe...